
The supply of critical raw materials is essential for European innovation and Europe’s social prosperity. In 2023, the EU Commission listed 34 raw materials as "critical", i.e. not sufficiently available in Europe. The aim of this study was to provide the European Parliament with options for how research and innovation can ensure a sustainable and secure supply of critical raw materials.
Research and innovation (R&I) are key to maintaining and increasing the prosperity of European society while tackling global challenges such as climate change. A secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials (CRM) is therefore essential. This study aimed to provide a clear and more detailed understanding of the challenges in R&I and their respective contexts to support policy makers.
The study addressed the following questions:
The term 'critical raw material' was introduced in 2008 with the launch of the Raw Materials Initiative (RMI). One of the measures in the RMI was the creation and regular updating of a list of critical raw materials for the EU in order to focus on steps to increase security of supply. From 2023, the list of critical raw materials is supplemented by a list of strategic raw materials. The diversity of raw materials made it difficult to provide a clear overview of the status of their supply and importance for the EU economy at the time.
One objective was therefore to provide such an overview and at the same time emphasise special features of the raw materials markets. This overview was necessary in order to focus on the fundamental problems of a secure supply of raw materials as a pillar of European Open Strategic Autonomy. This includes, for example: Dependence on imports, concentration of supplier countries, access to European deposits, trustworthy suppliers with high standards in governance and environment, circular use of products including recycling of end-of-life materials and the availability of substitute options.
Furthermore, the project analysed various research and innovation measures such as funding programmes and international research agreements.
As part of the results, political options for action were developed: They consider the 3 following central pillars to EU parliamentarians: (1) strategic autonomy, (2) international competitiveness, and (3) sustainability and values.
In short; the EU could strengthen and expand its institutional and R&I capacities to develop effective solutions in technologically advanced areas. This requires additional resources for mapping and assessing CRM supply chains, as well as for R&I activities, especially for CRM that have not received sufficient funding to date.
Because R&I activities are international, the EU could combine strategic raw materials diplomacy with existing science diplomacy efforts. Raw materials diplomacy could also be extended to key nations in the CRM supply and waste chains.
Given that the relocation of activities to the EU, such as the opening of new mines, is likely to lead to controversy, the issue of legitimacy requires additional efforts. One example could be living labs for citizen participation. This requires the integration of the humanities and social sciences into technical R&I projects.
-> The EU considers the supply situation for 34 raw materials to be critical.
-> Each material presents unique challenges at every stage of the supply chain, from extraction to recycling, necessitating specific innovations.
-> Strengthening research and innovation within the EU is essential for autonomy, competitiveness, and sustainability issues
-> Die EU betrachtet die Versorgungslage bezüglich 34 Rohstoffen als kritisch. -> Jedes Material stellt auf jeder Stufe der Lieferkette, von der Gewinnung bis zum Recycling, einzigartige Herausforderungen dar, die spezifische Innovationen erfordern. -> Die Stärkung von Forschung und Innovation innerhalb der EU ist für Fragen der Autonomie, Wettbewerbsfähigkeit und Nachhaltigkeit von wesentlicher Bedeutung.