Development of a framework for comparative research on the implications and risks of innovations for a decarbonised energy system

Our energy system is changing. The shift away from coal and oil and the expansion of solar, wind and water power have far-reaching economic and social consequences. How can we understand the associated "wave" of technological innovation in a comparative way and assess both local and systemically relevant consequences and potential risks as early as possible?

This project aims to develop a new research framework for the comparative and systematic assessment of innovation impacts. The aim is to comprehensively analyse intended and unintended effects of energy innovations in order to increase the social benefit of innovations for the decarbonisation of the energy system.

Preparing for a new era

The next twenty years will be less about improving single technologies and more about designing and building new infrastructures, institutions and lifestyles. In science, this is referred to as transition, as the focus is on the shift from one state to another. The transformation of energy systems is an important example of this. If we really want to switch Europe's energy supply largely to renewable sources by 2050, we need far-reaching changes in energy supply and consumption.

The requirements for technical development are thus increasing significantly: technology must not only function smoothly and have as few negative consequences and risks as possible, it also has to make a relevant contribution to the far-reaching transformation of the energy system in the future. The research approach developed in this project aims to investigate whether and to what extent this is actually possible.

The project consists of three parts: First, a theoretical framework is developed on the basis of existing knowledge. This will focus on the idea that many of the consequences of technology only arise in connection with concrete forms of use. Technical innovations will therefore be described as a combination of technology and forms of use.

Secondly, the project will develop new research methods and rules for their application. And thirdly, the new research framework will be tested using a real-world example. Specifically, the project will focus on innovations that enable the decentralised generation, storage and use of renewable energies.

Publications

  • The role of users in smart energy pilot and demonstration projects: Evidence from Austria, Denmark and Norway (ITA-manu:script 24-01). / Ornetzeder, Michael; Bettin, Steffen; Christensen, Toke Haunstrup et al.
    2024. (ITA-manu:script).
  • Solarstrom im Netz. / Riedlinger, Denise.
    In: ITA-NewsFeed, No. www.oeaw.ac.at/ita/news, 18.03.2024.
  • Solar Power Grid integration. ITA Dossier No 75en (March 2024; Author: Michael Ornetzeder). / Ornetzeder, Michael.
    2 p. Wien. 2024. (ITA-Dossiers).

    -> The massive expansion of distributed photovoltaic (PV) systems requires additional grid integration measures. -> These measures affect distribution system operators, households or several actors simultaneously. -> A systematic comparison of the various options has shown that the consequences and risks for operators, the environment, and society vary considerably. -> There is a lack of legal and economic frameworks to better utilise the advantages of alternative measures with lower social and environmental risks.

  • Solarstrom im Netz. ITA Dossier Nr. 75 (März 2024; Autor: Michael Ornetzeder). / Ornetzeder, Michael.
    2 p. Wien. 2024. (ITA-Dossiers).

    -> Der massive Ausbau dezentraler Photovoltaik-Anlagen erfordert verstärkt Maßnahmen zur Netzintegration. -> Diese Maßnahmen betreffen dieVerteilnetzbetreiber, der Haushalte oder gleichzeitig mehrere Akteure. -> Ein systematischer Vergleich der Optionen zeigt, dass sich die Folgen und Risiken für Betreiber, Umwelt und Gesellschaft zum Teil erheblich unterscheiden. -> Es fehlt an rechtlichen und wirtschaftlichen Rahmenbedingungen, um die Vorteile alternativer Maßnahmen mit geringeren sozialen und ökologischen Risiken besser zu nutzen.

  • Assessment of Socio-Technical Configurations: Towards a new framework for studying societal implications of energy innovations (ITA-manu:script 23-01). / Ornetzeder, Michael; Udrea, Titus; Bettin, Steffen et al.
    2023. (ITA-manu:script).
  • Wird uns die Energiewende gelingen? / Ornetzeder, Michael.
    13.11.2022 ed. 2022.
  • Will we make the energy transition happen? / Ornetzeder, Michael.
    13.11.2022 ed. 2022.
  • Energiewende braucht breite Diskussion. / Ornetzeder, Michael.
    13.11.2022 ed. 2022.
  • Digital Futures – spannende Erkenntnisse auf der europäischen TA-Konferenz. / Riedlinger, Denise.
    In: ITA-NewsFeed, No. www.oeaw.ac.at/ita/news, 04.08.2022.
  • Projektstart. / Riedlinger, Denise.
    In: ITA-NewsFeed, No. www.oeaw.ac.at/ita/news, 15.12.2020.
  • 1

Conference Papers/Speeches

  • Oslo

    The Experimental Incumbent: A case study of smart energy systems in Austria

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker) & Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker)

    19 Jun 2024

  • Wien

    Konsequenzen der relationalen Wende für Forschungsmethoden in der Technikfolgenabschätzung

    Udrea, T. (Contributor), Bettin, S. ((Co-)Author) & Ornetzeder, M. ((Co-)Author)

    4 Jun 2024

  • Graz

    Unlocking Integration: A Case Study on Smart Energy Systems in Austria

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker) & Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker)

    7 May 2024

  • Trondheim

    Fast but problematic: Social and environmental implications of private PV battery systems versus community-based solutions

    Bettin, S. ((Co-)Author), Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker) & Udrea, T.-I. ((Co-)Author)

    27 Sep 2023

  • Wien

    Das Soziale zuerst: Institutionelle Arrangements und konkurrierende ideologische Visionen von Individualismus und Kollektivismus in der Energiewende

    Bettin, S. (Speaker), Ornetzeder, M. ((Co-)Author) & Udrea, T.-I. ((Co-)Author)

    6 Jun 2023

  • Wien

    Energiewende Folgenabschätzung: Theorie der Folgen, Folgenforschung und Energiewende: Projekt ExTRA

    Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker)

    27 Mar 2023

  • Wien

    Energiewende Folgenabschätzung

    Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker)

    10 Mar 2023

  • Karlsruhe

    Exploring side effects and risks of energy innovations using a configurational approach

    Ornetzeder, M. ((Co-)Author), Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker), Sinozic-Martinez, T. ((Co-)Author) & Bettin, S. (Speaker)

    26 Jul 2022

  • Karlsruhe (online)

    Sustainability Transitions and their societal implications. Towards a configurational framework for the systematic assessment of technology impacts side-effects of energy innovations

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker), Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker), Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker) & Bettin, S. (Speaker)

    8 Oct 2021

  • Rotterdam (online)

    Innovation as socio-technical configuration: Towards a relational approach for exploring effects and side-effects of energy innovations

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker), Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker), Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker) & Bettin, S. (Speaker)

    3 Sep 2021

  • Barcelona (online)

    Societal Implications of System Innovation: Exploring Alternative Socio-Technical Configurations in the Case of Household PV and Stationary Battery Systems

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker), Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker), Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker) & Bettin, S. (Speaker)

    1 Sep 2021

  • Toronto (online)

    The agency of socio-technical configurations: Effects and side effects of energy innovation

    Ornetzeder, M. (Speaker), Udrea, T.-I. (Speaker), Sinozic-Martinez, T. (Speaker) & Bettin, S. (Speaker)

    8 Aug 2021

  • 1

Duration

11/2020 - 06/2023

Project team

  • Tanja Sinozic-Martinez

Funding