Delphi Austria
Technology Delphi Austria
This study is an independent type of “technology foresight“ and part of the research programme “Delphi Austria“ commissioned by the Austrian Ministry of Science and Transport.
It is strictly Austria- and problem-oriented, relevant to implementation, decentrally organized and concentrates on innovation potential where Austria might have opportunities to achieve leadership in seven sectors:
- Production and Processing of Organic Food;
- Tailor-made New Materials (Focus on Metals);
- Lifelong Learning;
- Medical Technologies and Supportive Technologies for the Elderly;
- Mobility and Transport;
- Environmentally Sound Construction and New Forms of Housing;
- Cleaner Production and Sustainable Development.
The core component is a broadly distributed Delphi-Survey with altogether 1127 experts from science, business, public administration and user representation who participated in two rounds. The survey instruments were prepared by interdisciplinary expert panels for each sector separately in a bottom-up process. This design corresponds to the concept of a “Decision Delphi“ and helped to reveal views and perceptions of the participants, to structure and coordinate them in a decentralised process, in an area where developments are normally determined by a large number of independent decisions. The experts gave assessments on almost 300 technical and organisational innovations, with a view to their importance and exploitation potential for Austria within the next 15 years, as well as assessments on a multitude of related policy measures.
Analytical conclusions and implications derived from these results for technology policy include the following:
1. In certain areas Austrian research institutions or firms have already achieved leadership or have the potential to do so in a middle range perspective, especially through the application of high – if not the highest – technology in otherwise medium technology fields and, on the other hand, in markets in which Austria has lead market character because of a special demand situation (shaped for instance by legal regulation, social system, consumers' preferences etc.). In general, however, Austria has not yet accomplished the leap from a technology adopter to a technology developer.
2. Opportunities to achieve leadership exist in the following areas:
- Simulation models in construction processes
- High-tech steel and low weight materials
- Recycling of composite materials and mixed materials
- Low noise equipment for railways
- Cleaner production technologies (especially in metal and paper production)
- Wood as material in constructive applications
- Ecologically sound construction
- Organic food (seeds and breeding, conservation and analysis techniques)
- Technologies supporting life-long learning (tailor-made packages for further training, intelligent information agents, electronic learning media)
- Technologies supporting independent living for the elderly without losing personal contacts
- Substitutes for organs and functions (in conjunction with biocompatible materials, hybrid technologies).
3. Information- and communication technologies are part and parcel in almost all cases of successful or promising leadership but as independent technologies they only play a role in certain niches in the Austrian context.
4. A specific problem is that the time horizon anticipated and taken into account in innovation activities by firms and applied research is too short.
5. Isolated technological efforts are rarely promising: success in achieving leadership requires a wider approach, networking, cooperation between firms and research institutions, a linking of technical and organizational innovations and a critical mass of firms and research institutions.
6. Attitudes towards organizational innovations are more ambivalent, indicating a higher level of mistrust in their realizability.
7. As far as policy options are concerned, the most important measure is the strengthening of cooperation between research institutions and firms as well as among firms and research institutions themselves. Suggested measures include: actions promoting the development of clusters in future oriented core areas, the creation of new institutions for the coordination of interdisciplinary research focuses, a differentiation in research promotion between more routine and high risk long-term projects, the prescription of targets and continuous evaluation in project promotion and the setting up of pilot projects, especially on organisational innovations. For each of the seven sectors a wealth of more specific policy recommendations can be found in the volume devoted to sector-specific results of this technology foresight (Delphi Report Austria 2).
Delphi reports (only in german language, see "downloads"):
- Delphi I – Technologie Delphi I, Konzept und Überblick, Schriftenreihe Delphi Report Austria 1, ITA, Mai 1998
- Delphi II – Technologie Delphi II, Ergebnisse und Maßnahmenvorschläge, Schriftenreihe Delphi Report Austria 2, ITA, Mai 1998
- Delphi III – Technologie Delphi III, Materialien, Schriftenreihe Delphi Report Austria 3, ITA, Mai 1998
Downloads
Downloads
Publikationen
Publikationen
- (2002). Delphi Austria: An Example of Tailoring Foresight to the Needs of a Small Country, ITA manu:script, ITA-01-02, December. doi:10.1553/ITA-ms-01-02.DOIWebsiteDownloadRISENWBIB Abstract
The world-wide diffusion and recognition of Technology Foresight suggests that it is of value for quite diverse types of economies and societies. Its merit as an important tool of strategic intelligence for policy-making also in small countries and transition economies depends on a careful tailoring to specific needs. Practice of Foresight is rather diverse also among small countries, but approaches tend to be more selective in scope, have more specific goals, and put greater emphasis on demand aspects than in bigger countries. Austria’s first systematic Foresight programme (completed in 1998) is an example of an innovative approach adapted to the needs of a small country. This contribution shows how “Delphi Austria” was tailored to a small economy which had undergone a successful catch-up process and how the Foresight process as well as its results have been utilised. The specific goals of Delphi Austria and its approach are explained as a selective, demand-, problem-, and application-oriented Foresight exercise with a number of innovative elements. It has been built on a series of preparatory studies, expert panels, and two parallel large-scale Delphi exercises: a Technology Delphi in conjunction with a Society and Culture Delphi. Experiences with some other innovative elements are outlined: the modification of the classical Delphi towards a decision Delphi; a broader definition of the expert base; the focus on technological as well as organisational innovations; a higher degree of “finalisation” of measures; and the application of a so-called “mega-trends section” in a multiple function. The focus of the Austrian Technology Delphi has been on the following subject areas: Tailor-made New Materials (focus on metals); Production and Processing of Organic Food; Environmentally Sound Construction and New Forms of Housing; Lifelong Learning; Medical Technologies and Supportive Technologies for the Elderly; Cleaner Production and Sustainable Development; Mobilit
- (2002). Das ExpertInnen-Delphi: Methodische Grundlagen und Anwendungsfeld ‘Technology Foresight‘, ITA manu:script, ITA-02-01, Jänner. doi:10.1553/ITA-ms-02-01.DOIWebsiteDownloadRISENWBIB Abstract
Die Delphi-Methode ist im Kern ein relativ stark strukturierter Gruppenkommunikationsprozess, in dem Fachleute Sachverhalte beurteilen, über die naturgemäß unsicheres und unvollständiges Wissen vorhanden ist. Das ExpertInnen-Delphi hat unter anderem einen festen Platz im Rahmen von weltweit an Bedeutung gewinnenden Technology Foresight Projekten. Der Beitrag legt methodische Grundlagen dar und illustriert seine Anwendung am Beispiel des österreichischen Technologie-Delphi. Zum innovativen Ansatz des Projekts und des Einsatzes der Delphi-Methode gehören folgende Hauptelemente: der auf die spezifische Situation Österreichs zugeschnittene Vorausschau-Ansatz (selektiv, nachfrage-, problem- und umsetzungsorientiert); die Modifikation des klassischen Delphi zu einem „Entscheidungs-Delphi“; eine breitere Definition der ExpertInnenbasis; sowie die Orientierung an der „Total Design Methode“ für postalische Umfragen. Die Umsetzung dieser Designelemente und ihr Beitrag zum erzielten Response werden diskutiert, anhand einiger Gütekriterien belegt und mit einem Blick auf den Verwertungszusammenhang des Technologie-Delphi abgerundet.
The Delphi method is basically a structured group process through which experts assess issues on which knowledge is uncertain and imperfect by nature. Delphi procedures are applied among others in the worldwide expanding field of Technology Foresight. The paper explains basic elements of the method and illustrates its use within the Austrian Technology Delphi. The innovative character of this application case is constituted by the following key features: a Foresight approach tailored to country-specific needs (selective, demand-, problem- and implementation-oriented); modification of the classical Delphi towards a ?Decision Delphi?; broader definition of relevant experts; and use of the ?Total Design Method? in the postal survey. The contribution elaborates on the translation of these design elements as well as on effects on response rates and - (2002). Das ExpertInnen-Delphi: methodische Grundlagen und Anwendungsfeld Technology Foresight. In A. Bogner, B. Littig, W. Menz (Hg.): Das Experteninterview. Theorie, Methode, Anwendung, Opladen: Leske + Budrich (pp. 133-153)..
- (2002). Delphi Austria: an example of tailoring foresight to the needs of a small country. In United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) (ed.), International Practice in Technology Foresight, Vienna: UNIDO (pp. 125-151)..RISENWBIB Abstract
The world-wide diffusion and recognition of Technology Foresight suggests that it is of value for quite diverse types of economies and societies. Austria’s first systematic Foresight programme completed in 1998 is an example of an innovative approach tailored to the needs of a small country. This contribution shows how “Delphi Austria” was tailored to a small economy which had undergone a successful catch-up process and how the Foresight process as well as its results have been utilised. The specific goals of Delphi Austria and its approach are explained as a selective, demand-, problem-, and application-oriented Foresight exercise with a number of innovative elements. In addition to this, it is shown which impacts the results of Delphi Austria have had in research and technology policy.
- (2001). "The Austrian foresight program: organization and expert profile". International Journal Of Technology Management, 739-755..RISENWBIB Abstract
Austria’s first systematic Foresight program, run between 1996 and 1998, is examined as an example of a Foresight approach in a small country. Practice of foresight is rather diverse also among small countries, but approaches tend to be more selective in scope, tailored to more specific goals, and putting greater emphasis on demand aspects than in bigger countries. “Delphi Austria”, built on a series of preparatory studies, expert panels, and two parallel Delphi exercises, reflects these characteristics including a number of methodologically innovative elements such as the combination of a Technology Foresight with a Society and Culture Foresight. The objectives and approach of this novel element in Technology Foresight are described and exemplary results are presented. Another innovative element which had been developed in the latest German Delphi study, a so-called mega-trends section in Technology Foresight, is outlined and used to examine the general attitudinal profile of the expert base. A summary and a view on the diffusion and implementation of the outcomes of “Delphi Austria” conclude the article.
- (2001). Technology Foresight – more than fashion?. International Journal Of Technology Management, 653-660..
- (2001). Special Issue on Technology Foresight. International Journal of Technology Management, Vol 21, Nr. 7/8..
- (2001). Country report – Austria, In: European Science and Technology Observatory (ESTO), OST/CEST (coordinators), Monitoring Foresight Activities, Sevilla: Institute for Prospective Technological Studies/ESTO (pp. 12-35)..
- (2001). En busca de una posición de liderazgo en nichos de innovación – la prospectiva tecnológica en Austria, Arbeitspapier im Rahmen einer Initiative der UNIDO zu Foresight-Projekten für Lateinamerika und Länder der Karibik, UNIDO, Wien..
- (2000). Forecasting in Medicine: The Results of Three European Delphi Studies. European Journal Of Public Health, 114-119..
- (2000). Searching for leadership in innovation niches: Technology Foresight in Austria. Proceedings zur "International Conference on Technology Foresight: The Approach to and the Potential for New Technology Foresight", National Institute of Science and Technology Policy (NISTEP), Science and Technology Agency, Japan, Tokyo, März..
- (2000). Innovative Elemente des österreichischen Technologie-Delphi. In M. Häder, S. Häder (Hg.), Die Delphi-Technik in den Sozialwissenschaften. Methodische Forschungen und innovative Anwendungen, Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag (pp. 67-93)..
- (2000). Marktnischen mit Chancen auf österreichische Themenführerschaft, Eine Auswertung des Technologie Delphi. Noch unveröffentlichtes Manuskript. Retrieved from http://www.oeaw.ac.at/ita/fileadmin/redaktion/Downloads/Projekt-Ressourcen/GTdel99nisch.pdf.
- (2000). The innovation potential and thematic leadership of Austrian industries, An interpretation of the Technology Delphi with regard to the old structures/high-performance paradox. Not yet published manuscript. Retrieved from http://www.oeaw.ac.at/ita/fileadmin/redaktion/Downloads/Projekt-Ressourcen/GTdel99ind.pdf.
- (2000). "En busca de una posición de liderazgo en nichos de innovación: la prospectiva tecnológica en Austria", Paper im Rahmen einer Initiative der UNIDO zu Foresight-Projekten für Lateinamerika und Länder der Karibik, UNIDO, Wien..
- (2000). Austrian Foresight – In search for sustained competetiveness by solving societal problems. In Ministry of Trade and Industry and The Finnish Association of Graduate Engineers TEK (Ed.), Foresight at Crossroads. Technology foresight linking innovation policy to informed action, Helsinki: TEK (pp. 92-97)..
- (1998). Medizintechnik und Technische Lebenshilfen für ältere Menschen, Delphi Report Austria II. Ergebnisse und Maßnahmenvorschläge (pp. 141-170)..
- (1998). Technologie Delphi Austria: Österreichs Innovationspotentiale auf dem Prüfstand. Ita-Newsletter, 2-4..
- (1998). Umsetzung des britischen Foresight Programms. Ita-Newsletter, 14-15..
- (1998). Ein Blick in die Zukunft: eine Einschätzung österreichischer Experten zu medizinischen und gesundheitsorganisatorischen Fragen. Managmed, 33 -35..
Konferenzbeiträge/Vorträge
Konferenzbeiträge/Vorträge
-
03/03/2003
Georg Aichholzer:
Technology Foresight in Austria: Experiences with ‘Delphi Austria’
Seminar on Technology Foresight Practices and Methods for the Russian Federation, UNIDO, Vienna, March 3-4.
Other Lecture -
27/07/2001
Georg Aichholzer:
The Austrian Foresight Programme: Design
Impacts and Recommendations. Presentation at UNIDO videoconference with the Foresight Committee in Venezuela, July 27, Vienna.
Other Lecture -
17/04/2001
Georg Aichholzer:
The Austrian Foresight Programme: Design
Impacts and Recommendations. Presentation at UNIDO Videoconference with Foresight Committee in Peru, April 17, Vienna.
Other Lecture -
04/04/2001
Georg Aichholzer:
Delphi Austria: An Example of Tailoring Foresight to the Needs of a Small Country
Regional Conference on Technology Foresight for Central and Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States, organized by UNIDO in cooperation with the Government of Hungary, 4-5 April, Vienna
Other Lecture -
29/11/1999
Georg Aichholzer:
Technology Delphi Austria: A brief overview
Konferenzpapier zur Konferenz "Foresight at Crossroads", Helsinki
Other Lecture -
01/07/1999
Georg Aichholzer:
"The Austrian Foresight Programme: Overall Organisation and Technology Delphi"
Workshop "Foresight Methods: International and Hungarian Experiences", Budapest, 1.-2. Juli
Other Lecture -
30/03/1999
Georg Aichholzer:
"Innovative elements of the Austrian Technology Delphi"
ZUMA-Symposium "Research on the Methodology for the Delphi-Method", Mannheim
Other Lecture -
01/12/1998
Walter Peissl:
Delphi in Small Countries: The Austrian Approach
Presentation at the Workshop on Foreign Experiences with Technology Foresight, hosted by TeknologiRådet, Kopenhagen
Other Lecture -
29/10/1998
Georg Aichholzer:
"A comment on national technology foresight studies from the Austrian experience"
Comité de la Recherche Scientifique et Technique (CREST-Ausschuß), Rat der Europäischen Union, Brüsselber
Other Lecture -
28/10/1998
Georg Aichholzer:
"Delphi Austria: Innovationspotentiale und Maßnahmenschwerpunkte für eine zukunftsorientierte Technologiepolitik"
Bundeskanzleramt, interministerielles Kontaktkomitee der Fördereinrichtungen, Wienber
Other Lecture -
27/05/1998
Georg Aichholzer:
"Die Technologiezukunft Europas
Eine Vorausschau auf Basis von Experten-Delphis", 'IIR Personalkongreß', Institute for International Research, Wien, 27. und 28. Mai
Other Lecture -
14/05/1998
Michael Nentwich:
Präsentation der Delphi-Teilstudie "Umweltgerechtes Bauen und neue Wohnformen" im Rahmen eines Workshop im Bundesministerium für Land- und Forstwirtschaft
Workshop im Bundesministerium für Land- und Forstwirtschaft, Wien
Other Lecture -
14/05/1998
Christian Rakos:
Präsentation der Delphi-Teilstudie "Biologische Ernährung" im Rahmen eines Workshop im Bundesministerium für Land- und Forstwirtschaft
Workshop im Bundesministerium für Land- und Forstwirtschaft, Wien
Other Lecture -
14/05/1998
Präsentation der Delphi-Teilstudie "Umweltgerechte Produktion" im Rahmen eines Workshop im Bundesministerium für Land- und Forstwirtschaft
Wien, 14. 5.
Other Lecture -
30/06/1997
Georg Aichholzer:
Lebensbegleitendes Lernen in der Informationsgesellschaft: neue Rahmenbedingungen und Herausforderungen
Berufspädagogische Tage 1997, Klagenfurt – 2.7.
Other Lecture